In the digital age, YouTube music critics have made significant strides compared to traditional music criticism. This article introduces six renowned music reviewers on YouTube whose unique perspectives, professional analysis, emotional expression, and pop culture insights will help you understand music from a fresh angle.
YouTube music critics refer to a group of creators dedicated to providing in-depth analysis and interpretation of music on the YouTube platform. They primarily conduct comprehensive dissections of musicians, genres, albums, and the cultural elements behind them, while also exploring the era’s characteristics and social context reflected in music works.
If you wish to understand music from a fresh perspective and in a multidimensional way, consider exploring the following recommended YouTube music critics list.
#1 theneedledrop
If you’re searching for versatile YouTube music critics, don’t miss the theneedledrop channel, created by Anthony Fantano, the world’s most influential independent music reviewer.
Anthony’s musical vision is astonishingly broad, spanning hip-hop, rock, classical, electronic, pop, and even heavy metal music, covering nearly every mainstream genre. No wonder he’s hailed as “The Internet’s Busiest Music Nerd”.
Anthony provides in-depth and meticulous reviews for every music genre, evaluating numerous factors including lyrical expression, the quality of the song, album cover design, instrument timbre, and many more. Though his commentary occasionally employs sharp language, it is precisely this objectivity that has earned him widespread acclaim within the music criticism community.
Subscribers: 3.05M
Channel URL: https://www.youtube.com/@theneedledrop
#2 Rick Beato
With 5.26M subscribers and 1.9K videos, Rick Beato has become one of the best music critics on YouTube. Rick is not only a professional music critic but also a seasoned producer, so his assessment of musical quality primarily involves deep analysis of melodies, drum patterns, and harmonies.
Unlike other critics who focus solely on judging a song’s merits, Rick is dedicated to uncovering the subtle intricacies within music. This is vividly demonstrated in his columns such as “Why This Song Is Great” and “The 20 Greatest Rock Guitar Solos of All Time”, where readers can both appreciate his unique insights into classic works and feel the emotional resonance conveyed by the pieces.
Subscribers: 5.25M
Channel URL: https://www.youtube.com/@RickBeato
#3 Middle 8
Middle 8 is a seasoned music critic on YouTube who primarily analyzes albums, musicians, and other topics through faceless videos.
Unlike other critics, Middle 8 not only interprets the diverse elements within works through interviews and music clips but also delves deeper into the conceptual foundations behind artists’ creations, the cultural phenomena they reflect, and the historical contexts they illuminate.
If you prefer narrative-style music review videos, following Middle 8 is a great choice, for each video feels like listening to a compelling story.
Subscribers: 722K
Channel URL: https://www.youtube.com/@Middle8
#4 deep cuts
In an era dominated by critical music videos, the creator of deep cut stands out by breaking away from conventional critical approaches. Instead, he focused on exploring music genres and commenting on the ever-evolving modern music style.
And ultimately, he synthesizes his analysis and provides album guides to help music enthusiasts discover their favorite genres while continually experimenting with new ones to bring a touch of joy to their lives.
Now, it’s time to follow deep cuts to discover your favorite music with the album guides he has provided.
Subscribers: 197K
Channel URL: https://www.youtube.com/@deepcuts
#5 Abigail Devoe
Abigail Devoe was launched by Abby in 2001, who is a YouTube music critic specializing in nostalgic styles. Beyond being a music critic, Abby is also an avid vinyl collector, making her “Vinyl Monday” series immensely popular.
Every Monday, Abby selects a vinyl record from her personal collection for an in-depth analysis. Her reviews cover the artist’s creative motivations, release dates and locations, background information, album content, as well as personal reflections.
Additionally, you can also tune in every Friday for Abby’s Double Album Recommendations series to discover more timeless classical music. If you’re a nostalgic soul, Abby’s carefully curated selection of retro music will take you on a magical journey through time.
By the way, if you have any questions about vintage fashion, you can also follow Abby for advice.
Subscribers: 63.3K
Channel URL: https://www.youtube.com/@abigaildevoe
#6 Rap Critic
As the name suggests, Rap Critic is a channel created by a YouTube music critic specializing in rap. If you love rap music, don’t miss it. The channel primarily reviews rap music each year, allowing you to browse playlists featuring tracks from specific years that interest you.
Rap Critic primarily shares his perspectives on various rap genres by analyzing the lyrics used in songs, the cultural concepts conveyed, and the underlying ideologies, ultimately delivering sharp critiques of the rappers themselves.
What’s more, Rap Critic has also compiled a rap lyric database. If you’re a rap music enthusiast looking to try your hand at creating your own rap music, you can find inspiration from the lyric database he shares.
Subscribers: 251K
Channel URL: https://www.youtube.com/@RapCritic
How to Save YouTube Music Critic Videos
YouTube music review videos often captivate viewers, so if you want to watch them offline anytime, consider saving them in bulk to your computer. Here, I highly recommend a free video downloader: MiniTool Video Converter.
MiniTool Video Converter is a safe and reliable video download tool that supports saving videos from popular platforms like YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, and TikTok. Additionally, the software allows downloading up to 10 videos simultaneously without a watermark.
The method to save YouTube videos with MiniTool Video Converter is straightforward: after downloading and installing the MiniTool Video Converter on your computer, paste the copied video link of YouTube music critics into the download box to analyze it. Then select your desired output format and resolution, and quickly complete the video download.
Now, you can click the button below to download MiniTool Video Converter and save the videos of the music critics on YouTube.
MiniTool Video ConverterClick to Download100%Clean & Safe
Final Words
No matter what kind of music you love, these six YouTube music critics recommended above will enrich your listening experience with diverse perspectives, taking you on a whole new musical journey.